August 16, 2017

Why We Love and Love to Hate the Kardashians

  • by Dr. Rachel Kitson
  • December 13, 2016
  • 0

Reality television, and its many iterations, is hard to avoid if you spend any time engaging in what has surely become one of America’s favorite pastimes: watchin’ the boob tube—well, scratch that, it’s more likely watching Netflix or Youtube at this point. Regardless, reality TV itself now covers a range of niche to ridiculous subjects including talent competitions; survival and fitness challenges; cooking and eating; building, buying, and selling homes; being a “real housewife” in various locales of the country; being a 4 people watching TVteenage mother; catfishing; plastic surgery; dating, marrying, divorcing (with and without clothes on,
and with or without knowing the person beforehand); living on the Jersey shore; and being famous for being famous. Arguably one of the most “successful” reality shows, which essentially spawned from a “leaked” sex tape, is Keeping up with the Kardashians. The show has 10 seasons and has been airing since 2007; it has led to a number of spin-offs including the anticipated Becoming Bruce, centered on Bruce Jenner as he comes out and lives his life publicly as Caitlyn (not with a K?!?!?), a transgender female.

“The show tends to polarize audiences—people either love it, love to hate it, or hate that it exists in the first place.”
The show tends to polarize audiences—people either love it, love to hate it, or hate that it exists in the first place. Those who tend to have more adverse reactions to the show and its concept tend to find the stars vapid, not interesting, self-absorbed, and addicted to attention. Those whoenjoy it may find it mindless and harmless entertainment, enjoy watching attractive people and keeping up with celebrity culture, or find the stars relatable and dynamic enough. I’ve watched the show occasionally when E! is on the TV at the gym, and have experienced the gamut of reactions to the show and its characters. There have been episodes, which I am not necessarily proud to admit, I have found enjoyable enough to watch for more than 10 minutes. I found the exchanges between the sisters to seem genuine and positive, and it was pretty and mindless—almost relaxing. There have been other times I have tuned in mid-episode and wondered how the heck this show was still on the air. It has no point and they all are egomaniacs.

Kardashian Sisters in blackOne of the more interesting things about the Kardashian family is that love them or hate them, they have been rampantly successful; at least what I would assume is their barometer of success. They practically run and own their own television station and are essentially a household name. You can’t go through the checkout line at the grocery store without being graced with a Kardashian or Jenner face. They seem to be a self-perpetuating well-oiled media machine. They are product of the social media world we live in, and are very savvy to the fact that their viewers require instant gratification, constant contact and access, and lots and lots of FUN! Because the Kardashians provide an aspirational lifestyle, while still maintaining flaws and idiosyncrasies, many viewers use the show for escapism as well as validation. You don’t have to be of the Aryan race, be a size 0, or have a 140 IQ to be successful and have a fun life.

“At times it seems extremely scripted, using manipulative plot devices to stir up ‘tension’ and ‘suspense’ so transparent it’s insulting to the viewer.”
For those 5 not in the know, the show is about the Kardashian family, the patriarch of the same namebeing the former Robert Kardashian, who defended OJ Simpson for the murders of Nicole Simpson and Ronald Goldman. Robert died in 2003 of esophageal cancer. He was survived by his wife, Kris Kardashian, and 4 children: Kourtney, Kim, Khloe, and Rob. Kris re-married Bruce Jenner (Olympic gold medalist in the decathlon, 1972), and had two daughters: Kendall and Kylie. They live in Calabasas California. Major plot lines of the show tend to be recycled and include the demise of various marriages (Kim’s, Khloe’s, and Kris’), Kourtney’s boyfriend’s drinking, childbirth, various ‘misunderstandings’ and beefs between the sisters and friends, and occasional clashes and interactions with the celebrity world. Another common theme is the interplay between the “reality” of the show and the paparazzi and tabloids. The show simultaneously creates, manufactures, and perpetuates gossip about its own characters, while also ‘setting the record straight’ when the paparazzi ‘gets it wrong’ about one family member or another. At times it seems extremely scripted, using manipulative plot devices to stir up “tension” and “suspense” so transparent it’s insulting to the viewer.

Another reason the show and the family has been such a success is the fact that they have very blurred-to-no boundaries between their “work” and their “personal lives.” Even the more seemingly fabricated plotlines are probably exaggerated reenactments of the family’s daily life. For a period of time, up until recently when Bruce came out she was transitioning, the show seemed to serve more as a platform for advertising their brand and catapulting family members into other fame driven endeavors. Part of the Kardashian Sistersfamily’s success and 200 million dollar empire has to do with the fact that they make no qualms about shameless self-promotion and extending their brand and image/likeness to the highest bidder. There have been some poor and sketchy business moves, but they have basically fessed up and owned those too, banking on a goldfish memory public. They seem to have little to no fear of over exposure or to shy away from a scandal (even the contrived ones). They know the power of the constant newsfeed of social media and the transient nature of celebrity culture. They attach their name to other celebrities and get paid to make nightclub appearances, which some may feel cheapens their claim at celebrity status versus extremely prolific socialites. Those who feel they embody everything that is wrong with our culture may have some merit, but I think the Kardashians may mirror our culture more than shape or influence it.

“For all its repellant qualities, the show has reflected the changing definition of a family and the actual appearance of American society in general.”
For all its repellant qualities, the show has reflected the changing definition of a family and the actual appearance of American society in general. While the Kardashians are far from being humble or unconcerned with their physical appearances, they own it, and seem basically proud to flaunt their assets. Some may say this perpetuates a culture obsessed with body image and whatever flavor of the week constitutes body perfection, but that is nothing new and even before Narcissus human beings have been enraptured by their own appearance and derived some portion of their self-worth from it.

I’d like to do a case by case analysis of the various characters of the Kardashian/Jenner family beginning Kim Kardashianwith Kim, who I find to be the most boring, but the one who is also the face and brand of the show. Kim’s sex tape with Ray J (rapper, actor, brother of Brandy) was leaked February of the same year Ryan Seacrest partnered with the family in creating the reality TV show. This time period seemed to mark the emergence of the modern celebrity culture, and a revamping of the term “starlet.” The public seemed more interested in the friend of the talent than the talent themselves—perhaps because it’s easier to identify with the star’s friend, who truly could be “just like us” or even be us. There has probably always been a public interest into the lives of the rich and famous, but with the leveling field of the internet and mass/social media, new forums for voyeurism and self-promotion had arrived. For the Kardashian’s, this became a new market to exploit.

Bruce JennerKim is reviled by many for being famous for being famous. She often does come across as the doe-eyed and vapid middle sister. Regardless of her emotional or intellectual complexity, Kim also tends to come off as the most even-keeled in the family. She’s also offered some of the most supportive commentary on accepting Caitlyn/Bruce’s transition. Next post I will try to offer a breakdown of Kimberly similar to that I offered her husband a few years back (A Psychologist’s Perspective on Kanye West). I’ll then hope to cover Kourtney and Scott, Khloe and Rob, Kylie and Kendall, and last but not least Caitlyn/Bruce.

Previous «
Next »
Dr. Rachel Kitson

Rachel enjoys blogging about pop-culture through a psychological lens. Topics of interest include celebrity culture, disturbing trends, social media, and other existential predicaments. She has been interviewed by Vice, Refinery 29, Expert Beacon, and contributed to Politini and Entertainment Shrinkly podcasts.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Send this to a friend